« Never again | Main | Another long year »

December 30, 2010

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834a7d7a769e20147e0f4b741970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference I've had me a few:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jose Jimenez

Alas, cynicism isn't the right word: You're a realist (or, as I put it to my fiends, a disappointed optimist). I'm sure the good Professor could debate that with you, if he were so inclined...

Nonetheless: A real cynic doesn't care; he/she has lot all hope--and is bound in a world where nothing matters, because, well, nothing matters. Cynicism and nihilism share the same slippery slope toward something no one really wants to be, but too many become because it's the easiest course. To see the world in real terms--and accept it at face value, dealing with the issues at hand--is nothing more than being a grown-up. Sure, it may suck from time to time, and it's easy to develop a callous or two where the pressure is the greatest, but in the end you pick up, work the problem, move on and appreciate the results. Frankly it's a character trait that's all too lacking in people these days, and one that for as backhandedly complimentary as it may be, is one worth standing up for.

So keep being the romantic, closeted or not; and don't fall for the propaganda that cynicism is the catch-all for the disappointments in life. It's takes fortitude and wisdom to see through that, and if life has taught me anything you have both in quantities to spare.

NB Kudos for the Dr. Thompson reference in the 4th para... ;)

ea757grrl

Jose: Yeah, you're probably closer to it than I am; "the disappointed optimist" is probably closer to what I am. Its just that the good Professor's quote was on my mind in the wee small hours of the morning up in AK when this one came tumbling out, as I was trying to make some sense of some things that had been troubling me.

Eric Sevareid once said of his mentor Ed Murrow, "He wasn't an optimist about tomorrow, but he was an optimist about the day after tomorrow." I've often used that to describe myself. Probably closer to what I wanted to say, anyway. But, I saw the shot, and took it, and you know the rest. :)

Thanks for stopping in!

NB "Hey, Mr. Shepard! I think your Jose Jimenez is...A-OK. But what you're doin' with it is b-a-d...." :)

Profmondo.wordpress.com

And of course, that line was spoken by the greatest player in the history of the Cincinnati Bengals (admittedly, that's like being the World's Tallest Midget), Anthony Munoz.

The thing about "Cynicism is my whiskey" (which I lifted from Bruce McCulloch, adding the second clause myself), is that whiskey is of course a kind of drug, and so is cynicism. Both are subject to abuse, and each can too easily become a kind of crutch. For what it's worth, I don't see that in you. As I tell my students, if you scratch a satirist, you'll find a moralist (e.g., Swift, Waugh, and some of Harlan Ellison's work). Likewise, you and I have had to develop carapaces of snark to cover the delicate tissues -- and the certainty that Things Matter even when we can't quite make them out -- beneath.

And just because I like the writing (and since I namechecked him in the previous graf), here's Ellison's version of your Preston Sturges analogy (from his short story, "Grail"):

"The great tragedy of my life is that in my search for the Holy Grail everyone calls True Love, I see myself as Zorro, a dark and mysterious highwayman -- and the women I desire see me as Porky Pig."

Fortunately, we've both found folks who from time to time are willing to see us as we'd like to see ourselves. Happy New Year, Nerd Girl.

ea757grrl

Prof: Many thanks for the kindness and understanding (and for dropping in, of course). Happy new year to you and yours, too.

The comments to this entry are closed.